In a scathing critique following the Kansas City Chiefs' disappointing 22-40 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl 2025, Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy didn’t hold back. The diehard New England Patriots fan slammed Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes and the team, declaring they “embarrassed themselves on a national scale.” Portnoy also dismissed any comparisons between the Chiefs and the Patriots dynasty, asserting that Mahomes is “not Tom Brady.”
Portnoy’s Harsh Assessment of Mahomes and the Chiefs
During an emergency press conference-style video shared on TikTok, Portnoy expressed his disbelief at the Chiefs’ performance. “Emergency press conference, still third quarter, but the Chiefs have embarrassed themselves on a national scale,” he said. “Absolutely demolished by the Eagles. Patrick Mahomes looks like a JV quarterback.”
Portnoy’s criticism didn’t stop there. He took aim at Mahomes’ inability to rise to the occasion, despite the quarterback’s previous successes. “Patrick Mahomes was awful. Couldn’t rise up, horrible throws. No protection, fine. Brady would have found a way,” Portnoy added, referencing Tom Brady’s legendary ability to perform under pressure.
Shutting Down Chiefs-Patriots Comparisons
Portnoy also shut down any comparisons between the Chiefs and the Patriots’ dynasty, emphasizing that the two teams are not in the same league.
“Now, it doesn’t take away from the fact they got three titles. It does stop the conversation - people comparing the New England Patriots’ dynasty and the Chiefs’ dynasty, they don’t even belong on the same field,” he said.
The Chiefs have won four Super Bowls in their history, with Mahomes leading the team to three of those victories (2019, 2022, and 2023). However, Portnoy argued that Mahomes’ achievements pale in comparison to Brady’s legacy. “The Chiefs would never ever beat the Patriots dynasty, not in a million years. Patrick Mahomes is not Tom Brady,” he declared.
Portnoy’s Dig at Mahomes’ Past Struggles
Portnoy didn’t shy away from referencing Mahomes’ past struggles, including a memorable moment when the quarterback appeared to vomit during a game. “Tom Brady has never puked on himself how Patrick Mahomes just did,” Portnoy quipped. He also acknowledged Mahomes’ dislike for Barstool Sports but insisted that his criticism was based solely on the quarterback’s performance. “I know Patrick Mahomes don’t like Barstool, big deal, but that’s not why. He was awful.”
Mahomes’ Legacy Under Scrutiny
Despite Mahomes’ impressive resume, which includes three Super Bowl titles and multiple MVP awards, Portnoy’s comments highlight the intense scrutiny that comes with being an NFL superstar. While Mahomes has often been compared to Brady as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, performances like the one in Super Bowl 2025 have led some, like Portnoy, to question whether such comparisons are premature.
As the Chiefs regroup after their crushing defeat, the debate over Mahomes’ legacy and his place among NFL greats is sure to continue. For now, however, Portnoy’s brutal assessment has added fuel to the fire, leaving fans and analysts alike to ponder whether Mahomes can ever truly measure up to the standard set by Tom Brady and the Patriots dynasty.