The New York Yankees are making significant moves this holiday season, with the signing of former MVP Paul Goldschmidt, further enhancing an already strengthened roster that includes Max Fried, Cody Bellinger, and Fernando Cruz. Paul Goldschmidt, the 37-year-old right-handed hitter, has agreed to a one-year, $12.5 million contract with the Yankees, bringing a wealth of experience to the team. Although Goldschmidt’s performance has seen a decline since his MVP-winning season in 2022, his addition represents an upgrade over Anthony Rizzo, Ben Rice, DJ LeMahieu, and others who played first base for the Yankees in 2024.
Four Gold Gloves and Consistent Offense
Goldschmidt’s career includes four Gold Glove awards for his stellar defensive play at first base, and he joins Cody Bellinger, a left-handed batter, in compensating for the departure of Juan Soto, who left for the Mets via free agency.
Goldschmidt made his MLB debut with the Arizona Diamondbacks, where he played until 2019 before being traded to the St. Louis Cardinals. A seven-time All-Star and winner of five Silver Slugger awards, Goldschmidt has accumulated 362 career home runs and boasts a lifetime batting average of .289. His solid performance against left-handed pitchers, particularly in 2024 when he hit .295 against them, will be a valuable asset for the Yankees.
Bellinger’s Move to Outfield
With Goldschmidt now in the fold, Cody Bellinger will primarily play as an outfielder for the Yankees. Bellinger is capable of playing all three outfield positions, including center field, which the Yankees hesitated to assign to Aaron Judge in 2024.
Yankees Infield Strategy and Future Moves
Goldschmidt’s signing also suggests the Yankees’ infield plans for 2025. DJ LeMahieu is expected to play third base, while Jazz Chisholm, Jr. will take over at second base after spending much of the previous season at third. The team may still pursue additional signings, with notable players like Alex Bregman and Nolan Arenado—Goldschmidt’s former teammate in St. Louis—remaining on the market. Bregman is still unsigned, while Arenado could be available via trade.
Additional Free-Agent Signings and Payroll Adjustments
The Yankees were able to make these moves thanks to the extra funds freed up when Juan Soto rejected their $760 million offer. Max Fried, the first player acquired by the Yankees this offseason, signed an eight-year, $218 million deal, marking a record for a left-handed pitcher.
End of Alonso and Walker Negotiations
With Goldschmidt’s arrival, negotiations with other potential first-base signings, including Pete Alonso of the Mets, appear to have ended. Meanwhile, Christian Walker, another free-agent target for the Yankees, signed with the Houston Astros earlier this week. Carlos Santana, another option, remains on the market.
Goldschmidt’s decision to join the Yankees represents a pay cut from his previous $22 million salary with the Cardinals in 2024, according to Roster Resource. Despite this, his signing should have a significant impact on the Yankees' chances in 2025.
