Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has sparked debate among fans after omitting Cristiano Ronaldo from his list of the club’s five greatest players. Scholes, a stalwart of Sir Alex Ferguson’s golden era, revealed his picks during a candid interview—and the absence of the five-time Ballon d’Or winner raised eyebrows, given Ronaldo’s historic contributions during two stints at Old Trafford.
The Portuguese superstar, who won three Premier League titles and a Champions League during his first spell, left an indelible mark on United. Yet Scholes’ selections leaned heavily on teammates who defined the club’s culture and longevity, sidelining even one of the game’s most iconic figures.
Scholes’ Top Five: Legends Who “Embodied United’s Soul”
In a conversation with TNT Sports, Scholes ranked his all-time Red Devils greats, prioritizing loyalty, leadership, and transformative impact over individual accolades. Here’s his lineup, counted down from fifth to first:
5. Eric Cantona
“The missing link who took us over the line,” Scholes said of the French maverick. Cantona’s swagger and clutch performances in the mid-90s revitalized United, laying the foundation for a dynasty.
4. Bryan Robson
A childhood hero for Scholes, Robson epitomized the all-action midfielder. “He could do everything a United midfielder should—tackle, lead, score. A complete player,” he remarked.
3. Roy Keane
Scholes hailed Keane as the “manager on the pitch.” “He defended, attacked, and dragged us through games. His influence was unmatched,” he added, referencing Keane’s ferocious leadership.
2. Wayne Rooney
The former England captain’s “raw power and technique” earned him a spot. “His goalscoring and versatility were sensational. A joy to play alongside,” Scholes noted.
1. Ryan Giggs
Topping the list, Giggs’ 23-year tenure—from teenage winger to midfield general—sealed his legacy. “He electrified crowds for decades. Whether sprinting past defenders or dictating play, he was United,” Scholes declared.
Why No Ronaldo? Context Behind the Snub
Scholes’ criteria leaned heavily on sustained influence and club identity. While Cristiano Ronaldo’s first spell (2003–2009) saw him evolve into a global icon, his turbulent 2021 return—marked by public clashes with Erik ten Hag and an early exit—likely diluted his legacy in Scholes’ eyes.
The midfielder, who shared a dressing room with Ronaldo during his rise, prioritized players who embodied United’s ethos across eras. Giggs’ 40-year association with the club, Keane’s captaincy, and Rooney’s selfless versatility contrasted with Ronaldo’s more transactional second act.
Scholes’ picks also reflect a reverence for Ferguson’s core leaders—figures who shaped the club’s DNA during its most dominant phase. Ronaldo’s brilliance, while undeniable, perhaps lacked the emotional resonance of those who spent their prime years solely at Old Trafford.
Scholes’ list isn’t just about skill—it’s a tribute to longevity and intangible impact. While Cristiano Ronaldo’s 145 goals and countless trophies cement his place in United lore, his exclusion underscores the weight of legacy beyond stats. For Scholes, greatness at United isn’t just about moments—it’s about molding the club’s soul.