The New York Giants’ search for a new starting quarterback has hit a snag after Super Bowl champion Matthew Stafford opted to stay with the Los Angeles Rams, effectively removing himself from the race. Stafford’s decision to restructure his contract leaves the Giants scrambling to explore other options as they aim to rebuild following a dismal 3-14 season.
With Stafford off the table, the Giants have narrowed their focus to three potential candidates: Aaron Rodgers, Russell Wilson, and Sam Darnold. But who will ultimately lead the team’s resurgence? Here’s the latest on their quarterback conundrum.
Mew York Giants Forced to Pivot
Matthew Stafford’s decision to remain with the Rams was a blow to the Giants, who had reportedly targeted the veteran quarterback as their top choice. Stafford, who led the Rams to a Super Bowl LVI victory, restructured his deal to stay in Los Angeles, leaving New York to explore alternatives.
According to Connor Hughes of SNY, the New York Giants are now shifting their attention to three main options: Aaron Rodgers, Russell Wilson, and Sam Darnold. Each brings a unique skill set, but the Giants must weigh their pros and cons carefully as they look to turn the franchise around.
Russell Wilson emerges as the front-runner
Among the trio, Russell Wilson appears to be the most likely candidate to land in New York. The former Seattle Seahawks star, who spent last season with the Pittsburgh Steelers, is set to become a free agent and isn’t expected to re-sign with Pittsburgh after a lackluster campaign.
Hughes noted that Wilson is the Giants’ “most likely outcome,” citing his experience and leadership as key factors. While Wilson’s recent form has been inconsistent, his track record as a nine-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion makes him an attractive option for a team in need of stability.
Aaron Rodgers: A long shot with potential
Aaron Rodgers’ name has also surfaced in discussions, but the New York Giants’ interest appears to be more speculative than concrete. The four-time MVP, recently released by the New York Jets, remains one of the most talented quarterbacks in NFL history. However, his age (40) and recent injury history make him a risky investment.
“Rodgers has been discussed by the Giants, but it hasn’t gone any further than that,” Hughes reported.
While Rodgers’ arm talent and football IQ are undeniable, the Giants may hesitate to commit to a player whose best years might be behind him.
Sam Darnold: The wildcard option
Sam Darnold, a former first-round pick, rounds out the Giants’ shortlist. Once hailed as the future of the Jets, Darnold has struggled to live up to expectations but remains a serviceable option. At 26, he offers youth and potential upside, making him an intriguing fallback if the Giants miss out on Wilson or Rodgers.
Darnold’s familiarity with the New York market could also work in his favor, though his inconsistent performances raise questions about his ability to lead a rebuilding team.
The Rookie Factor: Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders?
While the Giants are focused on landing a veteran, they’re also eyeing the draft to secure a long-term solution. According to Hughes, the Giants are considering a trade for the No. 1 overall pick, with Washington State’s Cam Ward emerging as the consensus top quarterback prospect.
“All felt any trade to No. 1 is for one player: Ward,” Hughes wrote. However, the Giants could still take a gamble on Shedeur Sanders, the son of Deion Sanders, though Hughes noted they’d be “on an island with their evaluation” if they did.
What’s Next for the Giants?
With Stafford out of the picture, the New York Giants’ quarterback search has entered a critical phase. Whether they land Wilson, Rodgers, or Darnold, the decision will shape the franchise’s trajectory for years to come. As the offseason unfolds, one thing is clear: New York is determined to find a leader who can restore pride to Big Blue.
