Home
Following India’s catastrophic 244-run defeat against New Zealand in the fourth ODI at Bay Oval, Mount Maunganui on November 13, stand-in captain Shreyas Iyer stood firmly behind his batters, insisting that the dramatic collapse to 89 all out was the result of exceptional seam bowling and shifting pitch behavior rather than reckless shot selection.
ADVERTISEMENT
Iyer’s protective post-match assessment, however, stood in stark contrast to the blunt, unforgiving critique delivered by head coach Gautam Gambhir. While the skipper attributed the meltdown to the pitch transforming from a flat track into a seamer-friendly surface, Gambhir refused to accept external factors as excuses, warning the squad that such collapses pose a severe threat ahead of the 2027 ODI World Cup.
Shreyas Iyer defends batters after '89' nightmare in 4th ODI vs NZ
Tasked with chasing a stiff target of 334, India’s batting lineup unraveled inside 26.4 overs. Speaking at the post-match presentation, Iyer acknowledged that New Zealand spearhead Matt Henry bowled brilliantly with the new ball, while emphasizing that the Bay Oval surface behaved entirely differently in the second innings compared to when New Zealand batted.
"We saw it, there was a huge difference in the first innings and the second innings in terms of wicket, but also credit where it's due, the way Henry bowled in the right areas right from ball one. I think that was sensational," Iyer said at the post-match presentation.
ALSO READ: IPL 2027 Trade: Mohammed Shami linked with RR move as LSG discuss Sam Curran trade
Iyer explained that after watching New Zealand’s batters play confidently on the rise to post 333, the Indian dressing room believed the pitch was a batting belter and felt confident about cruising through the run chase. However, once India walked out to bat, the movement off the seam made it nearly impossible for batters to commit to their strokes.
"When we got into the dressing room, we thought that we would be cruising through the chase as well. But the way the ball was seaming in and out, you couldn't basically decide from inside that this is how I'm going to play. Or even if you saw the wickets, no one threw the wicket away. It was good deliveries," Iyer added.
Looking ahead to Sunday’s fifth and final ODI at the same venue, Iyer urged his side to put the heavy loss behind them, analyze their shortcomings with both bat and ball, and draw confidence from the two matches they had already won earlier in the series.
Gautam Gambhir’s blunt critique contradicts captain’s remark
Iyer’s explanation—that the deliveries were simply too good and that no batter threw their wicket away—clashed directly with the message delivered by head coach Gautam Gambhir. Where Iyer saw unplayable movement and a changed surface, Gambhir saw a failure of application and accountability from seasoned international batters.
Addressing the media after the humiliating loss, Gambhir rejected the notion that Henry’s opening spell was impossible to survive, sounding alarm bells over India’s recurring middle- and top-order fragility.
"There are no unplayable deliveries in international cricket. Matt Henry bowled in good areas but we should be able to negate that. You are always concerned when you get bundled out for 90 odd. These are conditions close to World Cup. Even previous game we lost seven wickets, its a concern," Gambhir stated at the post-match press conference.
The diverging viewpoints between captain and coach highlight the pressure mounting on the Indian camp. While Iyer sought to shield his dressing room from demoralization ahead of a series decider, Gambhir made it clear that hiding behind pitch conditions would not prepare the team for tournament cricket.
Henry's first-over demolition and India’s batting fiasco
India’s chase of 334 was effectively over before it had even begun, thanks to a historic opening over from Matt Henry, who was returning to the side from a concussion layoff. Making full use of a strong crosswind and lively seam movement, Henry dismantled India’s three most accomplished batters inside six deliveries:
Rohit Sharma (0 off 1 ball): Caught by Finn Allen on the very first delivery he faced, failing to open his account.
Virat Kohli (0 off 4 balls): Clean bowled by a sharp delivery from Henry, departing without scoring.
Shreyas Iyer (0 off 1 ball): Trapped plumb leg-before-wicket on the final ball of the opening over, completing a triple-wicket maiden.
With Rohit, Kohli, and Iyer all back in the pavilion for ducks, India were left staring at an unbelievable 0 for 3 after the first over. Tall pacer Kyle Jamieson compounded the misery from the other end by removing Ruturaj Gaikwad for 5, reducing the visitors to 9 for 4 inside the powerplay. India limped to 26 for 4 after ten overs—their lowest powerplay total in an ODI since the 2023 World Cup.
ALSO READ: Henry's 6-for bundles out India for 89, New Zealand register huge 244-run win to keep series alive
Talking about the match, Shreyas Iyer won the toss and elected to bowl first, a decision New Zealand’s openers quickly punished. Will Young and Tim Seifert put on a dominant display, attacking India’s pace attack and punishing poor fielding. India dropped multiple chances—allowing Young vital reprieves early in his innings—and the right-hander made them pay dearly.
Young anchored the Black Caps’ innings with a superb 125 off 108 balls (14 fours, 4 sixes), while Seifert provided brisk momentum at the top with 58 off 48 deliveries. Finn Allen chipped in with a quickfire 41 off 30 balls in the middle overs before late contributions from Mitchell Santner (24) and Kristian Clarke (22) propelled New Zealand to 333 all out in exactly 50 overs. For India, Axar Patel was the standout bowler with 2 for 39, while Auqib Nabi (2/59) and Gurnoor Brar (2/69) claimed two wickets apiece.
In reply, following the early devastation caused by Henry and Jamieson, only Ishan Kishan (27 off 53) and Axar Patel (21 off 36) offered brief resistance, stitching together a 44-run stand for the fifth wicket to guide India past the 50-run mark. However, Matthew Fisher broke the stand and tore through the lower-middle order to finish with 3 for 31. Naman Dhir struck two sixes in a brisk 21 off 24 balls, but Matt Henry returned to clean up the tail, shattering Arshdeep Singh’s stumps to finish with career-best figures of 6 for 27.
Bundled out for 89 in 26.4 overs, India suffered their second-largest defeat by runs in ODI history (behind only their 245-run loss to Sri Lanka in 2000). With the five-match series now stands at 2-1, Sunday’s finale at Bay Oval will test whether Iyer’s faith in his batters or Gambhir’s demand for sterner resolve prevails.
ADVERTISEMENT
