Toronto Blue Jays may be forced into swift action if Bo Bichette’s future in Toronto takes a different turn. With uncertainty surrounding their franchise shortstop, the organization could pivot quickly toward a proven superstar to avoid a major void in the infield.
One name increasingly tied to that scenario is Trea Turner.
Trea Turner emerges as logical contingency plan
Turner remains one of Major League Baseball’s most established shortstops, combining elite athleticism with sustained offensive production.
If Bichette signs elsewhere in free agency, Toronto Blue Jays would need an immediate stabilizer at one of the game’s most demanding positions, and Turner fits that profile better than almost anyone available.
His resume and presence would allow the Blue Jays to maintain competitiveness rather than entering a transition phase during an important window.
Contract, age, and performance still favorable
Trea Turner is set to earn $27.2 million as he enters his age-33 season in 2026. While that figure is significant, his recent performance suggests he still provides strong value.
Historically, shortstops at this age have shown minimal decline, and Turner continues to impact games with his ability to hit for average, reach base, and pressure defenses with elite speed.
Even with mild indicators of regression, his overall offensive output remains among the best at his position.
Defensive growth adds to Toronto’s appeal
Defensive reliability would be critical if Toronto loses Bo Bichette, and Turner showed notable improvement in 2025. After earlier struggles in Philadelphia, his fielding rebounded following focused work with infield coach Bobby Dickerson. That defensive turnaround strengthens his case as a dependable option up the middle.
Health remains the main concern, particularly with hamstring issues in recent seasons, but Trea Turner’s sprint speed and athleticism still rank among the league’s elite.
Why a trade makes sense for both teams
From Philadelphia’s standpoint, moving Turner could create financial flexibility while opening opportunities for younger infielders as part of a long-term strategy.
For Toronto Blue Jays, he represents a rare chance to replace a departing star with another proven cornerstone rather than a risky stopgap.
If Bo Bichette leaves, the framework for a Turner deal becomes realistic, positioning the Blue Jays to remain firmly in contention.