The Suryakumar Yadav dilemma: Why the T20 maestro has failed in ODI cricket?

Team India Suryakumar Yadav.
Team India Suryakumar Yadav.

Highlights:

Understanding Suryakumar Yadav’s dominance in T20Is requires a deeper dive into his cricketing prowess.

When discussing T20I greats, Virat Kohli’s achievements are often cited.

Suryakumar Yadav, recognized as the world's premier T20I batter, recently dazzled the cricketing world with a magnificent performance in his first match as the Indian team captain. Playing against Australia, Yadav's explosive innings of 80 runs off just 42 balls, featuring 9 boundaries and 4 sixes, propelled India to achieve their highest-ever run chase in T20Is.
Follow the Sports Tak channel on WhatsApp

This recent exploit starkly contrasts Yadav's showing in the ODI World Cup 2023. In that tournament, he accumulated only 106 runs across seven matches, averaging 17.67 with a strike rate of 100.95. This disparity in performances across formats has further fueled the narrative that Yadav’s prowess in T20Is significantly overshadows his ODI batting.

Understanding Suryakumar Yadav’s dominance in T20Is requires a deeper dive into his cricketing prowess. When discussing T20I greats, Virat Kohli’s achievements are often cited. Kohli’s record of 4000+ runs at an average of 52.73 in 115 matches, including 15 player of the match awards, is a testament to his mastery in the format. However, at 35, Kohli is no longer the foremost choice in India's T20I setup, having not played a T20I since India’s loss to England in the T20 World Cup.

Enter Suryakumar Yadav, who since his induction into the Indian T20I team on March 14, 2021, has shown extraordinary impact. In just 54 T20I matches, Yadav has earned 12 player of the match awards. His rapid approach to closing in on Kohli’s record, despite playing significantly fewer matches, speaks volumes about his impact.

Yadav’s struggles in ODIs, however, present a different story. Despite being given ample opportunities before the ODI World Cup, Yadav was unable to firmly establish his position. With 37 ODIs under his belt, he has scored 773 runs at an average of 25.76, a performance that typically might have led to a player being dropped. However, the Indian management, led by Rahul Dravid, continued to back him, recognizing his potential and skill set.

The reasons for Yadav’s differing performances in ODIs and T20Is can be attributed to several factors:

Batting Position: In T20Is, Yadav has a defined role similar to his position at Mumbai Indians. He excels in a high-risk approach batting at No. 3/4/5, contributing significantly after the openers. His average soars to 53.73 at No. 4, playing 29 matches with 1182 runs. His 360-degree batting style thrives outside the powerplay, complemented by the shorter format’s intensity.

ODI Positioning: Contrarily, Yadav's batting position in ODIs has been inconsistent. Used as a floater, he often bats for 50-60 balls, aiming for maximum impact. However, his average has not crossed 40 in any position except No. 3.

IPL Experience: Yadav's extensive T20 experience, with 264 T20 and 54 T20I matches compared to 139 List A matches, has shaped his gameplay. His limited exposure in ODIs and the Indian team's attempt to provide him with a defined role, especially with KL Rahul's presence as an anchor, has restricted his opportunities in the 50-over format.

Limited Opportunities in ODIs: On average, Yadav faces about 20 balls per ODI match, insufficient for a batter of his caliber in the challenging 50-over format.

While Suryakumar Yadav has the potential to excel in ODIs, factors like limited time at the crease and a sparse ODI schedule might continue to widen the gap between his T20I and ODI performances. His T20I achievements reflect his adaptability and skill in the shorter format, but the journey to replicate this success in ODIs remains a work in progress. As the cricketing world watches, the question remains whether Yadav can bridge this gap and become a formidable force in all formats of the game.

 

MORE ON SPORTS TAK:
CSK release statement on Ben Stokes's future ahead of IPL 2024 mini-auction

R Ashwin lauds Australia's masterlcass in World Cup 2023 final, says 'What Pat Cummins did with the ball was...'