Mike Florio insists Tyreek Hill could leave Dolphins, challenges Adam Schefter's report

Pro Football Talk's Mike Florio has come out to contradict Adam Schefter's position on a potential Tyreek Hill departure from the Miami Dolphins. Florio thinks Hill is likely to be traded by Miami, suggesting Kansas City and Pittsburgh as potential destinations.

In a recent report on Monday, the sportswriter reported that if the Dolphins don't improve after their Week 1 defeat to Indianapolis, Hill may leave. He wrote:

“Week 1 could be a bad sign of things to come for Miami. Here’s the point, for now. If it continues, receiver Tyreek Hill will be this year’s Davante Adams. Although Hill is signed through 2026, he’s due to make $36 million next year - with a cap number of $51.89 million. It’s highly unlikely he’ll be back after 2025.”

Meanwhile, top NFL insider Schefter has denied a possible trade by the Dolphins involving Tyreek Hill. Appearing on the "Pat McAfee Show," Schefter responded to the question of the wide receiver's future at Miami. He said:

“I don’t know about him going to the Chiefs, and I don’t think the Dolphins are thinking of trading Tyreek Hill now, but if the season continues to go this way, obviously, you’d have to think that all options will be on the table at that point in time.”

Ultimately, the two experts are in agreement on the effect the Dolphins' performance might have on Hill's future with the franchise. Miami started the new season on Sunday with a huge 33-8 defeat to the Colts.

Hill led the Dolphins in receptions with four catches for 40 yards. The team's only touchdown came from an 11-yard pass by Tua Tagovailoa caught by De'Von Achane.

Questions raised by Tyreek Hill's week 1 performance

Tyreek Hill's disappointing performance on Sunday raises concerns that are beyond a one-time slip in performance. PFSN's Brandon Astreicher mentioned that wideout was briefly evaluated by the medical team during the game on Sunday.

However, the biggest problem is not Hill's fitness. Rather, it is the steady downfall that has been creeping into his output for the Dolphins. In 2024, he only caught 81 times for 959 yards and six touchdowns. Just a season earlier, he had made 119 receptions for 1,799 yards and 13 touchdowns.

Therefore, if the Dolphins decide to audit their team in the likely case of a poor run, Hill may be deemed past his peak.