NFL veteran umpire Carl Paganelli retires after 25 seasons on the field

NFL umpire Carl Paganelli has officially retired after a distinguished 25-season career, according to Mark Schultz of Football Zebras. Paganelli’s tenure, which began in 1999, marked a legacy of consistency, professionalism, and excellence in one of the league’s most demanding officiating roles.

A career rooted in dedication

Carl Paganelli joined the NFL as an umpire and remarkably remained in that position throughout his entire career. Over the years, he became a familiar and respected figure across the league, serving on officiating crews led by some of the most recognized names in the business. These included Bernie Kukar, Phil Luckett, Johnny Grier, Walt Anderson, Walt Coleman, Gene Steratore, Larry Nemmers, Jerome Boger, Ron Winter, Ron Torbert, Alex Kemp, Brad Rogers, John Hussey, and Tra Blake.

Postseason regular and Super Bowl veteran

Throughout his career, Paganelli was trusted to officiate in 22 postseason games, a testament to his skill and reliability. His impressive playoff resume includes four Super Bowl appearances: Super Bowl XXXIX, XLI, XLVI, and XLVIII, an honor reserved for the league’s most elite officials.

Family legacy in officiating

The Paganelli name is well-known in NFL officiating circles. At one point, three members of the Paganelli family were active officials in the league. Carl’s brothers, Perry and Dino, both served as back judges and retired prior to Carl, closing a significant chapter in NFL officiating history.

Injury ends final season early

Carl Paganelli’s final season in 2024 was cut short after a collision with a player. The incident occurred as he attempted to retrieve a ball being tossed in from the sideline, forcing him to sit out the remainder of the season. Prior to his NFL career, Paganelli worked as a probation officer, showcasing a lifelong commitment to public service.

Brandon Ellison named as successor

To fill the vacancy left by Paganelli, the NFL has brought in Brandon Ellison, son of veteran umpire Roy Ellison. Brandon joins a cohort of six new officials entering the league for the 2025 season, signaling a new generation of talent on the field.