Another San Francisco Giants star opts for free agency, ending four year stint

San Francisco Giants will be moving forward without one of their tallest and most talked-about pitchers, as right-hander Sean Hjelle has officially elected free agency after four seasons with the franchise. The team confirmed the news on Friday, November 7, 2025, marking the end of Hjelle’s tenure in San Francisco — one that combined flashes of promise with inconsistency and off-field controversy.

Sean Hjelle parts ways after four-year tenure

After joining the Giants organization in 2022, Hjelle’s time in San Francisco saw both encouraging development and frustrating setbacks. Over his four-year stint (2022–2025), the 6’11’’ pitcher compiled a 7–8 record with a 5.11 ERA, striking out 145 batters in 149.2 innings.

Hjelle appeared poised for a more defined bullpen role in 2024, where he logged 58 appearances and maintained an impressive 3.90 ERA, showing significant improvement in command and consistency. However, the 2025 season proved to be a difficult one for the towering pitcher, as he struggled to a 7.80 ERA, shuttling between the majors and Triple-A Sacramento.

The Giants’ decision not to extend Sean Hjelle’s contract signals a mutual parting of ways, allowing the 28-year-old pitcher to explore new opportunities with other clubs this offseason.

Off-field controversy clouds future

Hjelle’s free agency also comes amid ongoing off-field issues. In June 2025, his wife, Caroline Hjelle, publicly accused him of infidelity and abuse through a TikTok post, leading to an MLB investigation that remains unresolved.

Despite the controversy, the Giants retained Hjelle through the end of the season, suggesting the organization’s decision to await the league’s findings before taking further action. The investigation’s outcome could play a critical role in determining whether another franchise is willing to take a chance on the pitcher heading into 2026.

What lies ahead for Hjelle

Known for being tied as the tallest player in MLB history at 6’11’’, Sean Hjelle’s physical presence and raw pitching ability have always intrigued scouts. His sinker-cutter combination has shown flashes of effectiveness, particularly in middle-relief roles. However, with his recent struggles and legal uncertainty, it’s likely Hjelle will attract minor league or short-term offers rather than a guaranteed major league deal.