'I don't think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision': IND coach defends shocking call after Day 1

In the absence of Mohammed Siraj, India could not break the sixth-wicket partnership between Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips on Day 1 of first Test.

Profile

Arun Rawal

UPDATED:

google-icon
Mohammed Siraj, Ravindra Jadeja

India's Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja appeal to Shubman Gill for a review during day four of the fifth Test against England at The Kia Oval on August 03, 2025 in London, England.

Story Highlights:

Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja were dropped from the playing XI.

Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep were preferred over Siraj.

The Indian team management benched two senior players for the Test series opener against New Zealand in Wellington. Ravindra Jadeja and Mohammed Siraj did not make it to the playing XI, a decision that stunned many, including India batting great Sunil Gavaskar. India were impressive in the first session as the hosts lost four wickets for 60 runs. Another wicket fell early in the second session, but then the conditions eased up for batting, and India missed the services of Siraj, their leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship (WTC) 2025-27. As Henry Nicholls scored a ton and Glenn Phillips neared his, the BlackCaps finished Day 1 on a high. But India’s batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the decision to drop Siraj in pace-friendly conditions. 

"There is nothing wrong with Siraj. We thought this was the best XI when we picked the side. I don't think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision. This is just the first day. We don't pick a team only for day one, but also for days two, three and four," Kotak told reporters at Basin Reserve, Wellington. 

Siraj was picked for ODIs and Test series. He was sent to play a four-day game against New Zealand A, where he bagged a fifer. He warmed the bench for the first four ODIs. When Gurnoor Brar was added to the Test squad and left the ODI camp, Siraj played the final ODI and helped India win the series. But despite him being the leader of the pace attack in Bumrah’s absence, Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep were preferred over him. 

Why Sundar was picked ahead of Jadeja?

Kotak also explained the rationale behind picking Washington Sundar over India’s preferred overseas spin-bowling all-rounder Jadeja. He said that the number of left-handers in the Kiwi lineup led to the decision. 

"We preferred Washy as their top order had four left-handers. For this match, this is the best possible bowling attack," he said.

Sundar did the holding job to help the tired pacers recuperate. He bowled 16 overs, including two maidens, and conceded 38 runs. He could not provide a breakthrough. 

ALSO READ: Atkinson's nasty bouncer leaves Green concussed, Duckett's ton & Baker's 4-fer hands Aussies series defeat

Kotak on Kamboj’s pace drop

Kamboj did well with the new ball, getting opener Devon Conway out caught behind. He bowled as many as four maidens in 18 overs, conceding 57 runs but his pace dropped considerably. Kotak defended him as well.

"Yes, pace matters only in the third spell. Kamboj's speed is 130, 128, maybe a few balls at 126. That's fine," he said.

Kotak doesn’t want Krishna to be blamed

While Kamboj and Akash Deep picked one wicket each and were economical as well, Prasidh Krishna leaked runs. Picked ahead of an in-form Brar, who won the ‘Player of the series’ for taking nine wickets in the ODI series, Krishna was expensive early on. Eventually, the hit-the-deck bowler went for 58 runs from 16 overs he bowled. Kotak feels that Krishna’s criticism is unfair. 

"Prasidh, we know, is an attacking bowler and we know he would go for a few runs. When he gets wickets, we like it. When he gets hit, we don't like it. That's an unfair way to look at him," he said.

The only chance Krishna created was in the 74th over. The short ball ploy almost paid dividends. Nicholls went for the pull shot, but he got a top edge. It would've been an easy catch for backward square leg. Wicketkeeper Pant went for the catch too, but neither of them made a clear ball. Seeing Padikkal, Pant pulled out. But Padikkal was distracted by Pant in his peripheral vision and dropped an easy catch. 

ALSO READ: Absent from 2 IPL seasons, ex-DC batter Yash Dhull slams 125 to equal 13-year-old SMAT record

Nicholls-Phillips get the credit on sunny day

Kotak also praised Nicholls and Phillips for keeping Indian pacers at bay. He feels that the pitch dried up quickly due to the sunny conditions and there wasn’t much help for the bowlers when the ball got older. 

"Since the weather was good and it was a sunny day, the moisture dried up quicker than it happens. They batted well. Give them credit. They didn't even chance against the spinner. The new ball had more help for the bowlers," he said.

New Zealand were 243/5 in 82 overs at the end of Day 1's play. Nicholls scored 113 runs from 221 deliveries, including 14 fours. Phillips remained unbeaten on 94 off 182 balls, featuring 13 fours. Their sixth-wicket partnership is already 173 runs from 53.4 overs. 

This is already New Zealand's second-highest sixth-wicket partnership against India in the format. The record for the highest sixth-wicket stand against India by a Kiwi pair belongs to Brendon McCullum and BJ Watling. 12 years ago at the same venue, they had shared a 352-run stand, rescuing their side from 94/5.

“I was sort of rushing a little bit to get ready to the top to be honest. But yeah, I mean obviously they bowled incredibly well and we know when we play here that that can be the challenge when you lose the toss and get put in. But I think all the guys worked really hard and it was just nice to have that partnership from the middle session right through the end of the day,” Nicholls said about walking out early in the innings and scoring a century. 

What does India need to do on Day 2?

If India are to make a comeback, they need to use the windy conditions of Wellington early in Day 2’s play. The second new ball is just two overs old. Bumrah would look to take his maiden Test fifer on New Zealand soil. But he will need support from the other end, someone needs to do the ‘dirty work’ of bowling into the wind as India bowling coach Morne Morkel had specified in the pre-match press conference.

The batters have had ample practice in the Kiwi conditions during the three-game four-day series. They need to make their first innings count. India's highest innings score in Wellington is 438. 

India vs New Zealand 1st Test Playing XIs -

New Zealand: Tom Latham (c), Devon Conway, Henry Nicholls, Rachin Ravindra, Daryl Mitchell, Tom Blundell (wk), Glenn Phillips, Nathan Smith, Kyle Jamieson, Matt Henry, Jacob Duffy.

India: KL Rahul, Yashasvi Jaiswal, Devdutt Padikkal, Shubman Gill (c), Rishabh Pant (wk), Washington Sundar, Dhruv Jurel, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj, Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna.

    Share