Home
A prominent NFL analyst recently dropped a bombshell take on Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts, sparking fiery debates across the league. Fresh off a Super Bowl LIX MVP performance, where Hurts torched the Kansas City Chiefs for 300+ total yards and three touchdowns in a 40-22 rout, the 26-year-old phenom seemed untouchable. Yet, amid the confetti and celebrations, this analyst dared to question Hurts’ place among the NFL’s elite passers.
While fans laud the Eagles star for delivering their second Lombardi Trophy, one voice insists Hurts’ ceiling isn’t as high as the hype suggests. What’s behind this divisive stance? Let’s unravel the hot take.
Where Jalen Hurts stands in the quarterback debate
The criticism came from ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky, who stirred the pot during a First Take segment. Despite Hurts’ flawless 3-0 record against top-tier QBs like Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, and Josh Allen—and his clutch Super Bowl heroics—Orlovsky argued Hurts lacks the “talent” to join their ranks.
“I don’t think there’s anything Jalen can do to be in the conversation with [them] as players,” he stated bluntly. “The Super Bowl elevates the perception of him, but talent-wise, I don’t think Jalen is ever going to be in that group.”
The take feels puzzling when stacked against Jalen Hurts’ résumé. In 2023 alone, he outdueled Allen in a 37-34 overtime thriller, bulldozed Burrow’s Bengals with four touchdowns, and edged Jackson’s Ravens in a gritty 24-19 win. His stats in those games—combined 700+ yards, nine touchdowns, and zero turnovers—paint a portrait of a quarterback thriving under pressure. Yet Orlovsky doubled down, framing Hurts as a “game manager” rather than a game-changer.
Hurts, ever composed, shrugged off the label when asked earlier this season.
“Everybody can be called that depending on the day,” he replied. “It’s the quarterback’s job to execute, play clean football, and initiate the plays called.”
Translation? Results speak louder than rhetoric. With two Super Bowl appearances in three years—doubling the combined total of Burrow, Jackson, and Allen—it’s hard to argue with his formula.
The numbers vs. the narrative
Critics often fixate on Jalen Hurts’ “simplified” passing schemes, ignoring his knack for rising in high-stakes moments. His 8-0 post-bye run in 2024 wasn’t flashy, but it was ruthlessly efficient. While peers like Allen and Jackson pile up highlight-reel plays, Hurts prioritizes ball security and situational IQ, turning potential disasters into calculated wins.
Yet Orlovsky’s critique underscores a deeper bias: the reluctance to crown quarterbacks who win with grit over glamour. Hurts’ style—a blend of poised throws, bruising runs, and pre-snap mastery—might lack the dazzle of a no-look pass, but it’s propelled Philly to the mountaintop twice. Whether that’s enough to silence doubters remains unclear. But for Eagles fans, one truth is undeniable: Hurts isn’t just managing games—he’s mastering them.
In an era obsessed with quarterback rankings, Jalen Hurts’ success forces a reckoning. Is greatness defined by stats, splash plays, or simply winning? While analysts dissect his “talent ceiling,” Hurts keeps stacking trophies. Love him or doubt him, his track record suggests he’s too busy rewriting expectations to care about the noise.
