'You ever see Rohit defend balls on 4th or 5th stump?': Virat Kohli's idol during U19 WC days explains difference in technique of recently retired duo

Herschelle Gibbs compared the batting techniques of India's senior duo Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma and rated the latter as more technically sound.

Profile

Sports Tak

UPDATED:

Herschelle Gibbs, Rohit Sharma, Virat Kohli

Herschelle Gibbs, Rohit Sharma share a laugh during IPL 2012; RCB's Virat Kohliin action in the ongoing IPL 2025.

Story Highlights:

Herschelle Gibbs feels Rohit Sharma is more technically sound batter than Virat Kohli.

In a video from Under-19 World Cup 2008, Kohli had revealed that Herschelle Gibbs was his favourite player

Kohli and Rohit retired from Test cricket before the England tour.

One of the most attacking South African openers, Herschelle Gibbs feels Rohit Sharma is more technically sound that Virat Kohli who considered him as his idol during Under-19 World Cup days. The senior duo retired from Test wicket within a short span this month. Since their retirement, videos of their batting has been shared widely on social media. One of those videos is a comparison of how both batters have tackled spin in Test cricket of late. 

"This is the real difference between them, Kohli tries to play the same type of shot every time even if he gets out doing it He doesn't elevate his game But Rohit literally tries different kinds of shots every time, even in his worst form. Kohli doesn't have that ability to adapt, but Rohit does that's why Rohit has succeeded in playing fine Test cricket even after his mid-30s," a Twitter user wrote in the caption of the video shared. 

 

 

Gibbs reacted to the video saying that it is the job of the batting coach to help them explore more scoring options. 

"It’s up to the batting coach to give him more options to score no matter who the batter is.. thank me later," wrote the former Proteas batter. 

 

 

Then, one of the Twitter asked him who is a better batter among two as far as technique is concerned. 

"I disagree with u on that ... Virat technically is much better as compared to Rohit ... Remember, Rohit has been shifted up and down quite a lot ... Even today I'm not sure of which position he was comfortable to bat in Tests," replied the 51-year-old. 

 

 

ALSO READ: 'He doesn't want to be a normal cricketer, just doing a little bit...': Nasser Hussain on Virat Kohli retiring from Tests weeks ahead of England tour

Another Twitter used disagreed with Gibbs. Then, the veteran of 90 Tests, 248 ODIs and 23 T20Is talked about Kohli's vulnerability against the ball on the fourth and fifth stump of late leading to dismissals behind the stumps. 

"You ever see Rohit defend balls on the 4th or 5th stump ? How many times did Virat get out doing just that ? Rohit definitely technically better than virat," he further explained. 

 

 

ALSO READ: Delhi Capitals' replacement player Mustafizur Rahman heads to UAE for T20I series, set to miss GT clash even if he gets NOC from BCB

How Rohit, Kohli performed on their last Test tour

Rohit and Kohli's last Test series was on Australian soil. In the Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2024-25, Rohit missed the first Test and then managed to score 31 runs from five innings before opting out of Sydney Test. Meanwhile, Kohli started with a bang, scoring a century in Perth Test but he could not carry forward the momentum. 

    Share