'Sometimes vice-captains aren't brilliant captains': Michael Vaughan wants this player to lead England instead of Ollie Pope in Ben Stokes' absence

IND vs ENG 5th Test: Michael Vaughan feels Harry Brook is a better leader than Ollie Pope and should lead England in Ben Stokes' absence.

Profile

Sports Tak

UPDATED:

Harry Brook, Joe Root, Ollie Pope, Michael Vaughan

Harry Brook, Joe Root, Ollie Pope pose for a photo; Former England captain-turned-commentator Michael Vaughan.

Story Highlights:

Ollie Pope has won 3 Tests as captain so far.

Michael Vaughan feels vice-captains are not always good captains.

Vaughan wants Harry Brook to lead in Ben Stokes' absence.

Former England captain Michael Vaughan has backed white-ball skipper Harry Brook to lead the side in Tests in the future if Ben Stokes is unavailable due to injury. Vaughan feels that vice-captains don’t always fit in the role of captains. He named his former teammate and current assistant coach Marcus Trescothick as example to explain the current scenario as Ollie Pope is leading the side, owing to Stokes’ shoulder injury. 

"Harry Brook, to me, looks a leader. He looks a born leader," Vaughan told the Test Match Special podcast. "If Ben Stokes is injured in the future can't Pope stay as vice-captain and Harry Brook gets the leadership role?"

 

 

Strangely, Vaughan does not want Pope to be removed from the vice-captain role but does not want him to take over as captain when Stokes is injured.

"I look at someone like Ollie Pope, who looks a fantastic vice-captain. He is a brilliant person to have next to the captain to come up with ideas. Sometimes vice-captains aren't brilliant captains.

 

 

"Marcus Trescothick was a magnificent vice-captain for me but you wouldn't want to give him the captaincy,” he added. 

 

 

ALSO READ: AB de Villiers torments Pakistan bowlers, smashes 12 fours & 6 sixes in 60-ball 120 as South Africa chase down 196 to win WCL 2025 title

Vaughan not putting all blame on Pope for massive target

However, Vaughan feels that England are not chasing 374 in the ongoing fifth Test at Kennington Oval, London, because of Pope's captaincy. He blames the fielders for poor catching. Vaughan speculated that Pope's absence from the field for a couple of times was to heed tactical advice from an injured Stokes and head coach Brendon McCullum.

"It is not Ollie Pope's fault England are in this position. It is the dropped catches," said the 50-year-old.

 

 

ALSO READ: 'A small auction is coming in December. Some loopholes are...': MS Dhoni's message to CSK fans after finishing 10th in IPL 2025

"There were a couple of times he nipped off the field. It might have been for a comfort break, but it looked like he was going off for tactical advice.

 

 

 

"I don't know well enough and am not in the dressing room. I just want the best captain who is the best leader leading the England side. I don't think a good vice-captain will necessarily be a good captain."

 

 

Pope and Brook’s captaincy record 

Before the ongoing Test, Pope had led England in four Tests, emerging victorious in three whereas one ended in loss. 

Meanwhile, Brook has led England in eight ODIs and three T20Is. He has a 100 per cent record as captain in T20Is. Meanwhile, in ODIs, Brook has won five out of eight games as skipper.

    Share